Alfie Joshua Alfie Joshua is the editor at Auto in the News. Find him on Twitter, Facebook, and Pinterest.

Smartphone passcodes are protected by the Fifth Amendment

1 min read

For the handful of you who’ve never seen a courtroom scene in a movie or television show where the Fifth Amendment is used, it’s essentially the part of the Constitution that protects the convicted from being forced to incriminate themselves, hence the oft-used “right to remain silent” phrase. There are a few other things that the Fifth Amendment protects people from, but as with most things in the Constitution, it’s up to the courts to decide how and when those protections apply in the modern world. Applying centuries-old laws to our modern, technology-driven society can be difficult, and no decision the court makes will be unanimously supported. Such is the case with District Judge Mark Kearny’s recent ruling that people can’t be legally forced to hand over their smartphone passcodes. 

In a new case decided Wednesday, SEC v. Huang, a federal trial court in Pennsylvania held that the government can’t force a person to give up his passcode to his smartphone. I think the decision misses the mark, and I hope it is appealed. Here’s a rundown. First, the facts. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is investigating Bonan and Nan Huang for insider trading. The two worked at the credit card company Capital One as data analysts. According to the complaint, the two allegedly used their jobs as data analysts to figure out sales trends at major U.S. companies and to trade stocks in those companies ahead of announced company earnings. According to the SEC, they turned a $150,000 investment into $2.8 million. Capital One let its employees use company-owned smartphones for work. Every employee picked his own passcode, and for security reasons did not share the passcode with Capital One. When Capital One fired the defendants, the defendants returned their phones. Later, as part of the investigation, Capital One turned over the phones to the SEC. The SEC now wants to access the phones because it believes evidence of insider trading is stored inside them. But here’s the problem: The SEC can’t get in. Only the defendants know the passcodes. And the defendants have refused to disclose them.

Avatar of Alfie Joshua
Alfie Joshua Alfie Joshua is the editor at Auto in the News. Find him on Twitter, Facebook, and Pinterest.

Twitter can’t get in trouble for allowing ISIS activity…

Members of ISIS have been using social networks like Twitter to recruit new members and spread their propaganda, and many people feel that Twitter...
Avatar of Louie Baur Louie Baur
1 min read

The EU wants to force streaming services to show…

The dominance of American media across the globe means we don’t have to worry about our culture being drowned out by foreign media, but that...
Avatar of Alfie Joshua Alfie Joshua
55 sec read

A coalition of tech giants have written an open…

Ever since Apple refused to assist the FBI in cracking the San Bernadino terrorist’s iPhone, there’s been a massive debate about encryption in the United States...
Avatar of Chastity Mansfield Chastity Mansfield
1 min read

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *